The story primarily concerns the young and mysterious millionaire jay gatsby and his quixotic passion and obsession with the. Gatsby, the man who gives his name to this book, was exempt from my reaction g a t s b y, w h o r e p r e s e n t e d everything for which i have an unaffected scorn. Nov 04, 2018 especially compared to the more raucous 20 version, this is probably the closest movie we have to a page to screen adaptation of gatsby. The downside is that its somewhat low energy, and lacks a lot of the zip and wit of the novel. I dont know about you all, but if theres anyone who can look more like my mental image of jay gatsby than 38yearold robert redford, ive never laid eyes on them.
Gatsby does not grab tom and yell shut up in the novel, but does in the movie. May 20, 20 okay, this will be my last question relating to the great gatsby, i promise. The 1925 novel is considered an american classic and is one of the most widelyread books in modern america. In detail and dialogue the great gatsby largely adheres faithfully to f. Scott fitzgeralds the great gatsby tells the tale of a tangled web of love, lies, and liquor in the roaring 20s. The hotel scene in the movie differs from the novel for one main reason. In the book, tom simply sends daisy and gatsby away. The1974 movie has strengths and weaknesses when comparing it. The great gatsby 1974 the 1974 version of the great gatsby sometimes referred to as the robert redford great gatsby was hollywoods second attempt at adapting the novel, and by all accounts everyone involved was working a lot harder to do the book justice. Scott fitzgerald, films, literature, novels, the great gatsby, the great gatsby on may 24, 20. May 10, 20 like the directors other works, the great gatsby is noticeably, unmistakably luhrmanns and whether or not you believe in his vision is largely dependent on your tolerance of the mans idea of. Scott fitzgeralds novel, the great gatsby, and baz luhrmanns movie adaption can hardly be compared while entertaining and elaborate, the film doesnt stay true to the text.
The best way to enjoy baz luhrmanns big and noisy new version of the great gatsby and despite what you may have heard, it is an eminently enjoyable movie is to put aside whatever. There were some others that were changed slightly, either for filming reasons or for careless from the director. F scott was never treated for mental illness but he did. The story line would not have been the same without nicks. The great gatsbycomparison between 1974 movie and the book. The 1974 one with robert redford, the 2000 one with toby stephens, and the 20 one with leonardo dicap. Differences between the great gatsby book and movie book. The great gatsby, interpreted by baz luhrmann the new. The great gatsby book and movie comparison by emilee may on prezi. Scott fitzgeralds great gatsby was always fighting an uphill battle, but leonardo dicaprio, carey mulligan, and. Surprisingly, there were some facts that were left out, that in my opinion were critical for the story and the symbolism on it. May 10, 20 the best way to enjoy baz luhrmanns big and noisy new version of the great gatsby and despite what you may have heard, it is an eminently enjoyable movie is to put aside whatever.
The great gatsby is a 1925 novel written by american author f. The great gatsby, which was published in 1925, is a work of brilliant, finetuned clairvoyanceit sounded the death knell for a generation that was still alive. Which makes the fact that he really phones the role in that much. In 20, a movie adaptation of the book was released, attempting to recreate. Okay, this will be my last question relating to the great gatsby, i promise.
The great gatsby wednesday, june 5, 20 by lmccauley 1 comment whenever i see an adaptation of a good book, i walk into the theater or sit down in front of the television and tell myself that i must be prepared to handle the changes made to the story, however unreasonable they may seem to me. The great gatsby, interpreted by baz luhrmann the new york. Scott fitzgerald is the kind of book thats required to be read, at least my high school required that i read it. Film and novel comparison the great gatsby is a novel which critically discusses the ideals of the american dream and recapturing the past. Book to compare to the great gatsby the student room. It would be fun not to know that baz luhrmanns new movie is an adaptation, not to have read the book that its an adaptation of, not to bother. Scott fitzgeralds work, but some were better than others.
The great gatsby moviebook comparison by rachel altergott. I feel like every luhrmann film title should be prefaced with circus ring leaderesque embellishmentin the theaters this is a big deal, guys, the last time i went to a movie theater it cost four dollars, and then my mom asked me if i wanted to watch the. Ive heard several different opinions on gatsby, thanks to social media, and so far, it sounds as though everyone enjoyed it. Since the book came out in 1925, there have been several filmed versions of. Zelda actually wrote a novel of her relationship with fitzgerald while in a mental institution in maryland. How good is book compared to the film the great gatsby. The great gatsby moviebook comparison by rachel altergott on. The story primarily concerns the young and mysterious millionaire jay gatsby and his quixotic passion and obsession with the beautiful former debutante daisy buchanan. But, i must know, which version of the great gatsby is better. The great gatsbycomparison between 1974 movie and the. This gives the audience of the movie a reason for daisy to have doubts about gatsby, but this doubt is not portrayed in the novel. Scott fitzgeralds seminal book, it is almost impossible to have this discussion without addressing the other great. The list is quite long, and i add books onto it much more often than i cross them off. Which great gatsby movie is more like the book enotes.
Gatsby obsessive jon reiner analyzes the liberties that baz luhrmann takes. Like the directors other works, the great gatsby is noticeably, unmistakably luhrmanns and whether or not you believe in his vision is largely dependent on your tolerance of the mans idea of. May 22, 20 in the past seven days, ive seen two film versions of the great gatsby. May 09, 20 the great gatsby, which was published in 1925, is a work of brilliant, finetuned clairvoyanceit sounded the death knell for a generation that was still alive. Because if theres one thing the great gatsby needs, its more framing. Comparison of both the 20 and 1974 film adaptions of f. We have a complete guide to each of the great gatsby movie adaptations, as well as some advice. Spoilers of both the novel and the movie are included in this post, and this is a longer post than i normally blog, but considering the buzz around this movie, i thought it was warranted. Fitzgeralds nick does refer to gatsby as the man who gives his name to this book emphasis mine, so the idea that the great gatsby is a text written by nick is not entirely original with. Was born poor but then became rich and successful self educated and. Tom leaves for a phone call after talking with nick about the butlers nose.
Book versus movie adaptation gatsby obsessive jon reiner analyzes the liberties that baz luhrmann takes in adapting the novelwhat he gets right and what he gets wrong. Scott fitzgerald that follows a cast of characters living in the fictional towns of west egg and east egg on prosperous long island in the summer of 1922. There are some critics on the distaste for the music, but all in. A version of this article appears in print on may 10, 20, section c, page 1 of the new. It had a really large budget, brought in francis ford coppola to adapt the. I havent yet been able to see the 1974 version, yet, but i want to know what people think of it. Its a baz luhrmann film, so its colorful, visually appealing and full of pop music. If personality is an unbroken series of successful gestures. Words float in the air around the befuddled nick as he works on his book, and lines from. This adaptation shows a society gone crazy on alcohol, conspicuous consumerism, the emptiness of wealth, and hollow. The greater great gatsby the book the great gatsby has been depicted by lots of films, but the two that stand out the most are the 1974 and the 20 versions. Compared to jack claytons historically precise adaptation, baz luhrmanns version of fitzgeralds novel seems wildly flamboyant. The great gatsby is a 20 australianamerican romantic drama film based on f. Luhrmann, the films director and producer, caters to the pop culture appetites of our generation with hip hop soundtracks, whereas fizgeralds wrote with his 1920s audience.
He meets him at the dock and are then driven to the house. None of the movie versions of the book compared to f. The great gatsby 197420 sidebyside comparison youtube. Whenever i see an adaptation of a good book, i walk into the. The film was cowritten and directed by baz luhrmann and stars leonardo dicaprio as the eponymous jay gatsby, with tobey maguire, carey mulligan, joel edgerton, isla fisher and elizabeth debicki. Shiring xing miss pruitt english 3 february, 20 the great gatsby comparison between book and 1974 movie the difference between the developing way of books and movies is magnificently huge because the way of emotion transmitting is different. In the film adaptation, producer jack clayton stays very closely to the plot and even quotes the novel verbatim but fails to capture the essence of the themes portrayed in the novel. Thus, the 20 version of the great gatsby has costumes for the women that display much more decolletage than was revealed with the clothing of the roaring 20s and the mens pants have narrower. Actually, this is true of both the book and the film, but you cant exactly have nick unknowingly interacting with. Scott fitzgeralds seminal book, it is almost impossible to have this discussion without addressing the other great 1974 version starring robert redford and mia farrow. Differences between the great gatsby book vs movie page 1. The1974 movie has strengths and weaknesses when comparing it to the book as does the 20 version. Discuss the key differences between the novel and the film and why those changes were made. The great gatsby is a novel which critically discusses the ideals of the american dream and recapturing the past.
Over the past two weeks, i finally read through gatsby and watched both the 20 film adaptation and the 1974 adaptation. Comparing the movie the great gatsby and the book cram. Similarities and differences between the great gatsby the. The great gatsby moviebook comparison nick carraway similarities he is a meek, awkward background character differences depicted as a depressed alcoholic nick character in the movie seems to enjoy partying and lacks control in his life meyer wolfsheim east egg vs. Probably perception including like class and how peoples own emotions and experiences influence how they interpret certain events like the drama with gatsby, daisy and tom compared to brionys lies in atonement was only planning on mentioning the american culture for the context marks but not heavily but aw hope you find a book soon. Madeline petri i agree, and it was interesting to see how they incorporated it so easily into the film. Luhrmann, the films director and producer, caters to the pop culture appetites of our generation with hip hop soundtracks, whereas fizgeralds wrote with. How the movie is set up distracts from the core themes of. Leonardo dicaprio as gatsby, carey mulligan as daisy, and tobey maguire as nick carraway round out the cast of baz luhrmanns 20 version of the great gatsby. The great gatsby has been on my to read list of classic literature for a long time. The great gatsby nick carraway, in the mental house. Review the great gatsby 20 its reaching an interesting point when a movie that would under normal circumstances be positioned as a prestige film, usually to be released in the fall for oscar consideration and often with a respectable literary pedigree, is instead repurposed into a. Actually, this is true of both the book and the film, but you cant exactly have nick unknowingly interacting with gatsby when hes played by leonardo dicaprio.
831 227 1537 97 1086 313 1142 1083 1245 596 240 593 1196 799 1631 633 544 996 1612 1379 114 1374 90 818 1455 1393 687 1121 319 876 29